Watch on YouTube
Time Travels with Truffle: Dateline October 20th,
1973 – Washington, D.C.
The lights of the Oval Office burned well after nightfall on
October 20, 1973. Outside, Washington appeared calm. Inside the White
House, however, a decision was being made that would ultimately destroy a
presidency.
At the foot of President Richard Nixon's desk sat a
small reddish-orange Pomeranian named Truffle.
For months, Truffle had wandered through the corridors of
the White House as the Watergate scandal grew steadily worse. She had watched
aides rush from office to office, listened to tense conversations, and
witnessed the growing cloud hanging over the administration. While politicians
argued, lawyers maneuvered, and reporters chased leads, Truffle seemed to sense
something few people fully understood: the greatest threat to Nixon no longer
came from the original crime itself. It came from the way he was responding to
it.
The crisis had begun more than a year earlier. On June
17, 1972, five burglars were arrested inside the Democratic National
Committee headquarters at the Watergate complex in Washington, D.C. At first,
many observers assumed it was simply another political scandal. But
investigations by reporters, congressional committees, and federal prosecutors
gradually revealed connections between the break-in and Nixon's reelection
campaign.
The scandal deepened dramatically in 1973. Former White
House Counsel John Dean testified before Congress that a cover-up had
existed within the administration. Then came an even more shocking revelation.
Nixon had secretly recorded conversations in the Oval Office.
Those tapes became the center of a constitutional showdown.
The independent special prosecutor, Archibald Cox,
demanded access to the recordings. Nixon refused. The battle soon escalated
into a confrontation over the limits of presidential power and the rule of law.
On the evening of October 20, Nixon sat behind his desk
weighing his options. He had decided that Cox must be removed.
As the President reached for the telephone, Truffle suddenly
became unusually agitated.
She barked sharply.
She pawed at his chair.
She stood on her hind legs and nudged his arm.
Several aides smiled at the little dog and tried to distract
her. But Truffle returned again and again, whining and scratching at Nixon's
sleeve as though desperately trying to stop him.
The President absentmindedly scratched behind her ears. Then he picked up the phone. The decision had been made. Nixon ordered Attorney General Elliot
Richardson to fire Archibald Cox.
Richardson refused. Rather
than carry out the order, he resigned.
Nixon then turned to Deputy Attorney General William
Ruckelshaus.
Ruckelshaus also refused.
He resigned as well.
Finally, Nixon turned to Solicitor General Robert Bork,
who agreed to execute the order. Bork dismissed Cox. Within a matter of hours, the Department of
Justice had been thrown into turmoil. Two of the nation's highest-ranking
law-enforcement officials had resigned rather than obey the President's
directive.
The event immediately became known as the Saturday Night
Massacre.
As reporters rushed to telephones and presses around the
country, Truffle sat quietly beneath Nixon's desk. Even a small dog could see that something had
gone terribly wrong. The President had
hoped to stop the investigation. Instead, he intensified it.
The public reaction was swift and overwhelming. Newspapers
across America printed banner headlines. Editorial boards condemned the
firings. Members of Congress from both parties expressed alarm. Thousands of
Americans flooded congressional offices with phone calls demanding action.
Until that night, many citizens had been willing to give
Nixon the benefit of the doubt.
After that night, many no longer were.
The Saturday Night Massacre became a turning point in
Watergate.
The investigation not only survived but gained renewed
momentum. A new special prosecutor was appointed. Court battles over the White
House tapes continued. Public confidence in the President steadily eroded.
Over the following months, pressure mounted.
Then, in July 1974, the Supreme Court unanimously
ruled in United States v. Nixon that the President had to surrender the
tapes. When the recordings became
public, one conversation quickly became infamous. Known as the "Smoking
Gun" tape, it revealed Nixon discussing efforts to obstruct the FBI
investigation only days after the Watergate break-in.
The political damage was devastating.
Republican leaders who had remained loyal now informed Nixon
that impeachment and removal were virtually certain. The end came quickly.
On the evening of August 8, 1974, Nixon addressed the
nation from the Oval Office. He
announced that he would resign. For the
first time in American history, a President of the United States voluntarily
stepped down from office.
The following morning, Nixon departed the White House aboard
Marine One. Standing in the helicopter doorway, he gave his famous farewell
wave before disappearing into the sky.
Watergate was over.
Years later, White House staff still remembered the little
reddish-orange dog who would not leave Nixon alone on the night of October 20,
1973.
They laughed about it afterward, but some wondered whether
Truffle had somehow sensed the disaster ahead. Had Nixon simply complied with
the courts and allowed the investigation to proceed, historians have often
argued that his presidency might have survived.
Instead, the Saturday Night Massacre accelerated the very
downfall he had hoped to prevent.
One longtime aide supposedly summed it up best:
"Everyone in that room was trying to save Nixon from
the investigation. The dog was trying to save Nixon from himself."
And so Truffle became part of White House legend: a small
four-legged witness to one of the most consequential political mistakes in
American history, barking a warning that nobody would heed as a presidency
marched toward its inevitable end.
And once again, History is gently guided by a tiny paw.
